Northern Ireland Executive vs Irish Government: what the official data shows
A like-for-like comparison of outcomes, legislation, spending and staff, department by department, built only from official government and statistics-agency publications.
Data as at 17 November 2026 · Reviewed and updated monthly · Every figure links to its source below
Northern Ireland Executive (NI)Irish Government (ROI)
On five official outcome measures, the Irish Government performs better on four. The NI Executive performs better on road safety.
4measures where ROI leads
1measure where NI leads
This compares results, not effort. The two governments have different powers: the NI Executive has no tax-raising, defence or foreign-affairs powers and is funded mainly by the UK block grant. Each card notes where definitions differ.
At a glance
Ireland (ROI)
Ahead on 6 of 9 North–South comparisons
Northern Ireland (NI)
Ahead on 3 of 9 North–South comparisons
Warm, glowing colour marks the side ahead on more measures; the cooler colour the side ahead on fewer. Colour strength follows each side's share of the comparisons in the "North–South disparities" section below. The map shows government outcomes, not the people or places, and says nothing about constitutional arrangements. Boundaries and lakes: Natural Earth (public domain).
Counters
Day counts update every time the page is opened. Act counts are read from the official registers when the page loads; if a register cannot be reached, the figure from the last monthly check is shown and marked.
NI Executive
–
days in office since restored on 3 Feb 2024
–
days with no First Minister and deputy First Minister in office, Jan 2017 to Feb 2024
–
share of the time since 9 Jan 2017 without them
Acts passed this calendar year
NI
–
ROI
–
Waiting for a first hospital outpatient appointment
NI
–
per 1,000 people, 30 Jun 2026
ROI
–
per 1,000 people, 25 Jun 2026
Scorecard
Population-adjusted where the raw totals would mislead. NI population 1,928,400 (NISRA, mid-2025); ROI 5,458,600 (CSO, April 2025) or 5,525,600 (April 2026).
North–South disparities
Nine official measures of living standards and public services, sorted by which side is ahead. The South leads on 6 and the North on 3. These figures describe outcomes under the current arrangements. On their own they do not show what any constitutional change would produce.
Where the South is ahead
Where the North is ahead
Trends
Housing, road deaths and house prices are shown as an index (2016 = 100) so both jurisdictions can share one scale; actual figures are in each chart's table and tooltip. Waiting lists are per 1,000 people. Income is in purchasing power standards, which adjust for price differences so euro and sterling figures can be compared.
Laws passed each year
Acts enacted per calendar year · shaded years: no functioning NI Executive for most or all of the year · 2026 to 17 Nov
New homes completed
Index, 2016 = 100
Road deaths
Index, 2016 = 100 · lower is better
Hospital outpatient waiting lists
People waiting for a first consultant-led appointment, per 1,000 population · lower is better · gaps: no full NI count (new records system in the South Eastern Trust)
Employment rate
% of working-age people in work, annual · NI ages 16–64, ROI 15–64
Unemployment rate
% of the labour force, annual · lower is better · NI ages 16+, ROI 15–74
House prices
Official house price index, second quarter, rebased 2016 = 100
Disposable income per person
Household disposable income per person, purchasing power standards (PPS) · higher is better
Department by department
NI has 9 departments and ROI has 18. They are grouped here by function (our grouping, based on each department's published remit). Spending per head is in euro (ECB 2025 average rate, €1 = £0.85687).
Function
NI department
ROI department(s)
NI € per head
ROI € per head
NI Acts*
ROI Acts*
* Acts sponsored by the department since the current government took office (NI: 3 Feb 2024; ROI: 23 Jan 2025). NI totals exclude one Assembly Commission Act; ROI totals exclude one Private Member's Act. NI spending: 2025-26 voted budgets (net, including benefits). ROI spending: 2026 gross estimates. The bases and years differ, so treat spending as context, not as a performance score.
Context: spending and staff (not scored)
How to read this
Only official sources. Government departments, parliaments, statistics agencies (NISRA, CSO), the NTPF, PSNI and the RSA. One independent fact-checker is used for a single date (the 3 Feb 2024 restoration of the Executive) and is labelled as such.
Definitions differ. NI counts new homes from Building Control inspections and ROI from new electricity connections. Hospital waiting lists are counted under different rules. Employment age bands differ by one year (16–64 vs 15–64).
Laws are a crude measure. The Assembly legislates only on devolved matters, while the Oireachtas covers everything a sovereign state does, including EU law. Routine annual money (supply) Acts are excluded from the scorecard.
NI budget 2026-27. As at 17 Nov 2026, no Budget (No. 2) Bill for the 2026-27 Main Estimates appears in the Assembly's bill list for this mandate, so the NI figures use the last full voted year (2025-26).
What this shows
Options already on the record, for consideration
These options were put forward by official bodies, committees or recognised researchers. They are listed here, not endorsed, and the parties disagree on several of them. Each one links to where it was proposed.
Sources
Declaration. Prepared by Quintin QS. Every figure on this page was taken from the official source listed and checked against it at the date shown. Check the linked source before relying on any figure. Corrections are welcome and will be applied at the next monthly review.